SEC’s appeal won’t be a setback for XRP holders — Pro XRP lawyer

23 July 2023

Cointelegraph By Amaka Nwaokocha

John Deaton elaborated on the possible scenarios and intricacies of enforcing the summary judgment.

News

Join us on social networks

Amid speculations that a potential appeal by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) could negatively impact the crypto market, Pro-XRP lawyer John Deaton has made it clear that even in the event of an appeal by the agency, it would not significantly affect XRP (XRP) holders.

After the judge’s ruling that the programmatic sale of XRP tokens through exchanges does not classify them as securities, a new question emerges regarding the potential legal implications if the SEC decides to appeal against the ruling. Deaton, who represents more than 75,000 XRP tokenholders, elaborated on the possible scenarios and intricacies of enforcing the summary judgment.

On July 21, the SEC stated in its filing regarding the case against Terraform Labs CEO Do Kwon that it plans to request a review of the decision made in the Ripple lawsuit. This decision came after Kwon expressed his intention to utilize the XRP lawsuit verdict as a precedent to argue that digital assets should not be classified as securities.

An appeal is not even close to be a setback. First, it will be two years from now before a decision is issued by the 2nd Circuit, if it’s appealed. The Torres Decision is the law until then – at least in the 2nd Circuit. Second, even if the 2nd Circuit said Torres was wrong… https://t.co/GzW31D9edQ

— John E Deaton (@JohnEDeaton1)

July 22, 2023

Deaton’s explanation suggests that the appeal decision could extend over two years, during which the summary judgment will remain the governing law. It remains uncertain when the SEC will initiate the appeal process in response to the ruling.

“An appeal is not even close to be a setback. Don’t let anyone underestimate how significant this win is for XRP and XRPHolders and Ripple.”

In response to the ongoing discussion about the SEC’s authority over tokens, Stuart Alderoty, chief legal officer at Ripple, tweeted that the agency’s jurisdiction is limited to securities. He said if a token isn’t classified as a security, then the SEC should not have a role in its regulation. Claiming jurisdiction where none exists is merely a political power move, which ultimately benefits no one and harms everyone involved.

A securities agency only has jurisdiction over securities. No security, no role for the SEC.

Pretending to have jurisdiction when there is none, is simply a political power play. It helps no one; it hurts everyone. https://t.co/OhNSaDuJ26

— Stuart Alderoty (@s_alderoty)

July 22, 2023

Related: Terra interim CEO says any ‘little progress’ made gets derailed by accusations

Judge Analisa Torres’ July 13 ruling stated that XRP tokens are not securities when sold on retail digital asset exchanges. However, the decision was not entirely in the company’s favor because Ripple was found to have broken the securities laws when it offered XRP to hedge funds and other institutional buyers.

Magazine: Crypto regulation: Does SEC Chair Gary Gensler have the final say?

  

You might also like

Central banks testing smart contract toolkit under BIS Project Pine  
Central banks testing smart contract toolkit under BIS Project Pine  

Central banks are experimenting with smart contracts to implement monetary policy in tokenized environments, signaling a growing interest in integrating blockchain technology into traditional finance (TradFi).According to a joint research study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s Innovation Center and the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Innovation Hub Swiss Centre, smart contracts could offer central banks flexible, rapid-response tools in a tokenized financial system.The study, dubbed Project Pine, tested a prototype “generic customizable monetary policy tokenized toolkit” for further research by central banks, according to a BIS report published May 15.“The smart contract toolkit was fast and flexible,” the BIS wrote. “In hypothetical scenarios, the central bank was able to add and change tools instantly.”The report emphasized that if tokenization becomes widely adopted for money and securities, smart contracts could play a central role in how monetary policy is executed.Project Pine system overview. Source: BISRelated: Bitcoin more of a ‘diversifier’ than safe-haven asset: ReportThis marks a “first step” in highlighting the potential benefits of tokenization for central banks, according to the BIS.The framework “speed and consistency” was “validated” within a 10-minute hypothetical scenario where central banks quickly changed collateral criteria and exchanged liquid collateral for illiquid amid falling collateral values.The smart-contract framework also allowed central banks to deploy a new facility offering reserves and changing the interest rates on the reserves in an “immediate” implementation.Project Pine, smart contract operations. Source: BISRelated: Coinbase faces $400M bill after insider phishing attackSmart contracts, tokenization may help central banksSmart contracts and tokenization technology may help central banks’ rapid response to “extraordinary events,” the BIS report said:“This speed, coupled with the ability to adjust any of the parameters at any time, gives central banks flexibility in responding to unforeseen events and fast-moving crises.”While promising, the report also acknowledged that central banks will likely face infrastructure challenges, as most existing systems are not designed for these advanced use cases.Smart contract testing scenario. Source: BISProject Pine employed Ethereum’s ERC-20 token standard combined with another standard for “access control.”Financial institutions have increasingly embraced tokenization in recent years.At the Consensus 2025 conference, Joseph Spiro, product director at DTCC Digital Assets, called stablecoins the “perfect” financial instrument for real-time collateral management for financial transactions such as loans or derivatives.Magazine: Altcoin season to hit in Q2? Mantra’s plan to win trust: Hodler’s Digest, April 13 – 19

Stablecoin bill passes in Northern Marianas as House overrides veto  
Stablecoin bill passes in Northern Marianas as House overrides veto  

The Pacific US territory of the Northern Mariana Islands has passed a bill allowing its small constituent island of Tinian to launch a stablecoin, overriding an earlier veto by the territory’s governor.The 20-member Northern Mariana Islands House voted 14-2 to undo Governor Arnold Palacios’ April 11 veto of the bill, which allows the Tinian local government to issue licenses to internet casinos and includes a provision for the Tinian treasurer to issue, manage and redeem a “Tinian Stable Token.” The territory’s nine-member Senate had revived the bill on May 9, voting 7-1 in a two-thirds majority to override the veto, which then needed a two-thirds majority in the House to pass.Representative Marissa Flores (top left) had urged for “thoughtful deliberation” on the internet gaming and stablecoin bill. Source: YouTubeOriginally, a four-member Tinian delegation to the Marianas legislature had unanimously passed the bill to Governor Palacios on March 12.It may put the Tinian government in the lead to be the first US public entity to issue a stablecoin, which it must do before July if it’s to beat the state of Wyoming government, which is aiming to issue a stablecoin by then.Tinian has just over 2,000 residents and a largely tourism-based economy. Its local government, the Municipality of Tinian and Aguiguan, is one of four municipalities in the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, a US territory in the Pacific Ocean north of Guam.Governor Palacios said in a letter that he vetoed the bill as it “presents several legal issues and may be unconstitutional,” would regulate an activity that could not “be clearly restricted” to Tinian and that it lacked needed enforcement measures to counter illegal gambling.The stablecoin is called the Marianas US Dollar (MUSD) and will be backed by cash and US Treasury bills held in reserve by the Tinian Municipal Treasury, according to statements shared with Cointelegraph in March.The Tinian government chose local tech services firm Marianas Rai Corporation as the exclusive infrastructure provider for MUSD, which will be launched on the eCash blockchain, a network that rebranded from Bitcoin Cash ABC in 2021 and is a fork of Bitcoin Cash, a blockchain forked from Bitcoin.A Marianas Rai Corp. spokesperson did not comment beyond telling Cointelegraph the company would announce more on MUSD on May 19.“Bitter pill to swallow”Before the vote, House lawmakers heard from the public and discussed overturning Governor Palacios’ veto before they voted it through, with independent House floor leader Marissa Flores airing concerns over the bill.Marianas Rai Corp. co-founder and technology chief Vin Armani had urged lawmakers to undo the veto, saying the bill would “attract billions of dollars of investment and tax revenue” from the crypto industry without the government having to pitch in.Clyde Norita, a Marianas Rai Corp. director and local legal cannabis mogul, told the House that the local economy was “dying out” and the bill would allow business in the region “without affecting our culture, without affecting our environment, without affecting our immigration status.”Representative Flores, who voted against the override, said, “Every time we talk about casinos, there’s always some kind of bitter pill to swallow.”Related: Stablecoin regulation ‘next catalyst’ for crypto industry — Aptos head “It is true, we are in dire need of money, but what I don’t like is when we are desperate, and we are now forced to make a decision because we are desperate once again,” she added. “Every time we’re desperate, it always seems that we come back to casinos.”“I don’t like to be pushed to a corner to make a decision based on fear,” Flores said.Others were more supportive of the measure, with Republican Representative Patrick San Nicolas, a Tinian delegation member who initially voted on the bill, saying it would help pull the region out of “a deep economic crisis.”“We need this legislation to unlock our potential,” he added. “This bill does not depend on tourists or federal subsidies — it builds a digital industry generating revenue from a licensed jurisdiction.”Legal Panel: Crypto wanted to overthrow banks, now it’s becoming them in stablecoin fight 

Coinbase drops 7% on customer breach, SEC probe into user numbers  
Coinbase drops 7% on customer breach, SEC probe into user numbers  

Coinbase stock dipped after news broke of a cyberattack that exposed customer data and an ongoing Securities and Exchange Commission investigation over misstated user numbers in 2021.The double whammy of bad news rattled investors as company stock (COIN) slid 7% in a fall to $244 in after-hours trading on May 15, according to Google Finance.  Coinbase stock 24 hours. Source: Google Finance Coinbase has since confirmed the report from The New York Times, which stated the SEC has been investigating whether Coinbase misstated its user numbers in past disclosures, an inquiry that began during the Biden administration and has continued under the Trump administration.“This is a hold-over investigation from the prior administration about a metric we stopped reporting two and a half years ago, which was fully disclosed to the public,” confirmed Coinbase chief legal officer Paul Grewal to Cointelegraph. “We also disclosed – and continue to disclose – the more relevant metric of ‘monthly transacting users’ – the number of people who use our platform in a given month,” he said before adding: “While we strongly believe this investigation should not continue, we remain committed to working with the SEC to bring this matter to a close.” The regulator took specific umbrage at Coinbase’s claim of “100+ million verified users” that appeared in its marketing and IPO documentation in 2021. However, the exchange stopped reporting this metric in 2022.In its 2022 financial statement, the firm stated it would stop reporting the metric as it no longer believed it provided meaningful information to its business performance. Source: SECThe probe has continued despite the SEC dropping its 2023 enforcement lawsuit against Coinbase under the Trump administration. Coinbase has hired law firm Davis Polk & Wardwell to assist with its response to the SEC.Coinbase refuses to pay ransomOn May 15, Coinbase reported that it was attacked with a $20 million extortion attempt after cybercriminals recruited overseas support agents to leak user data.“These insiders abused their access to customer support systems to steal the account data for a small subset of customers,” the firm stated. Related: Coinbase to become the first crypto firm to join the S&P 500Coinbase refused to pay the ransom but said it would reimburse victims of phishing attacks as a result of the data breach, with expected remediation and reimbursement expenses ranging from $180 million to $400 million.Magazine: Metric signals $250K Bitcoin is ‘best case,’ SOL, HYPE tipped for gains: Trade Secrets

Open chat
1
BlockFo Chat
Hello 👋, How can we help you?
📱 When you've pressed the BlockFo button, we automatically transfer to WhatsApp 🔝🔐
🖥️ Or, if you use a PC or Mac, then we'll open a new window to load your desktop app.